[quewye]

It's a bad idea because you're essentially suggesting being able to write in your own little bubble, not even IN game but on the forums, and be rewarded for it.
Journals are part of the writing, yes, but all of it is drawn in from the game itself.
Your logs? Are from in game logs. The events and experiences you describe in your journal? From the game itself.

I didn't say dev items were the line. I MEAN that just writing a short story for an item (or two) is mega ???. You're getting things without any risk whatsoever. That's the thing - there is no work there.

Uh. I added some stuff to my Journals that didn't happen. Fluff it up. My [UNIQUE] sword smithing RP was done in the form of a biography--it got approved.

I got my affinity mostly from solo-training roleplay. In-game, yes, but it wasn't with other characters. I could've just as well made it a biography for the same achievement. A lot is already done in a bubble, even if not a bubble of your own, a bubble of a small roleplay group.

I achieved all of these with minimal risk. But apparently since crafting my unique didn't involve fighting a dragon, making three rolls to see if I'm BBQ, all after negotiating the division of Israel with a GM it shouldn't have been given such. I mean, all I did was write.